Social Media Is Part of Your Marketing Strategy. Not Your Entire Marketing Strategy

If you’re posting three times a week, creating beautiful Reels, watching your follower count grow, and still not seeing more bookings or revenue, it might be time to rethink your short-term rental marketing strategy.

Because here’s the thing:

Social media is part of your marketing strategy. It is not your entire marketing strategy.

For short-term rental owners, social media can be a powerful way to introduce your property to new people, build trust, create desire, and stay top of mind.

But the goal isn’t necessarily for someone to see one Reel on Tuesday and book your property for Wednesday.

That’s not how most people make buying decisions.

Instead, your social media should be one part of a larger marketing system. That system should move potential guests from discovery to trust and, eventually, to a booking.

And the key to making that happen?

Give them an easy next yes.

---

Your Guest Probably Isn’t Ready to Book Yet

One of the biggest mistakes I see with social media marketing is assuming the person who sees your content is ready to book right away.

Sure, it happens.

But in most cases, that’s probably not the typical customer journey.

Think about your own behavior as a consumer.

Maybe you discover a beautiful boutique hotel in Palm Springs. You immediately think, Oh my gosh, I want to go there.

The problem? You’re not actually planning a trip to Palm Springs.

So you follow the account.

A few weeks later, you see another Reel.

Two months after that, you see another one and save the post.

At this point, you’ve followed, liked, and saved. Even so, you still haven’t made a booking decision.

Now fast-forward six months.

Your anniversary is coming up, and you’re thinking about where you want to go for a trip. Suddenly, you remember that boutique hotel in Palm Springs.

Now there’s a reason to travel.

That property has gone from “That looks cool” to “That might be where we go.”

There could be eight months between the first interaction and the eventual booking decision.

So what was social media doing during those eight months?

It was creating:

• Awareness
• Familiarity
• Desire
• Trust
• Recall

Most importantly, you want to have enough touchpoints with a potential guest that when they finally have a reason to travel, your property is the one they remember.

That’s the job.

---

Build a Short-Term Rental Marketing Strategy Like a Spiderweb

I’ve talked about marketing strategy as a spiderweb before, and I think it’s a helpful way to look at how all of these pieces should work together.

Picture the outside edges of a spiderweb.

That’s where someone first discovers you.

Social media is really good at that.

Reels, shares, collaborations, local businesses, influencers, and search-friendly captions can introduce your property to people who have never heard of you before.

From there, the goal is to move them toward the center of the web.

That’s where things get sticky.

They know you, trust you, understand your property and understand the experience.

Eventually, they make a booking decision.

What we don’t want is a bunch of disconnected islands.

Instagram is on one island, your website is on another, your email list is somewhere else, your direct booking site is floating off in the distance.

There’s no easy way for a potential guest to get from one to the next.

Instead, your marketing should work like a spiderweb. Every piece should connect to another.

---

Give Your Potential Guest an Easy Next Yes

So what does that actually look like?

Let’s walk through a potential guest journey.

First, someone discovers your property through a Reel.

Maybe they found it through Instagram’s search page. Or perhaps someone shared it with them. They may have even searched a keyword that happened to be included in your caption.

Whatever the reason, they discover you.

Next, they visit your profile.

Your bio should quickly help them understand:

• Where you are
• What your property is
• Who it’s for
• What makes it different
• What they should do next

Then you give them an easy next yes.

Maybe that means clicking the link in your bio.

They land on your website and start browsing.

Now they can see the property, understand the amenities, experience the brand, and get a feel for what staying with you would actually be like.

Maybe they aren’t ready to book.

That’s okay.

Instead, they might be ready to download a local guide.

They might want an itinerary, want to enter a giveaway or want early access to seasonal dates.

Or perhaps they want a discount on their first direct booking.

The point is that the next step doesn’t have to be a booking.

It simply needs to be the next logical step.

---

Move People From a Platform You Don’t Own

There’s another really important piece of this strategy:

You don’t own Instagram, Meta or the followers you’ve built there.

The algorithm, you also don’t control that.

That doesn’t mean social media isn’t valuable. It absolutely is.

It simply means you shouldn’t build your entire business around something you don’t control.

One of the best things you can do is use social media to move people onto platforms you do own like your website, your email list or your direct booking site.

Once someone joins your email list, you have permission to continue the conversation with them directly.

That matters because your relationship with that potential guest is no longer completely dependent on an algorithm.

---

Your Email List Keeps the Conversation Going

Let’s say someone visits your website but isn’t ready to book.

Without an email opt-in, they might leave, and you may never hear from them again.

With an email list, though, you have an opportunity to keep the relationship going.

You could offer:

• A discount on their first booking
• A chance to win a free stay
• Early access to seasonal dates
• A local destination guide
• A curated itinerary
• A guide to your area’s best attractions
• Something specific to the experience your property offers

Once they opt in, you can introduce them to your brand through a welcome sequence.

A simple three-to-five-email welcome sequence can help someone understand the property, the experience, and why they should eventually choose to stay with you.

What if they still aren’t ready?

That’s okay, too.

You can continue the relationship through monthly newsletters or, at minimum, seasonal emails.

The goal isn’t to constantly sell.

Instead, it’s to stay relevant until the timing is right.

---

Your Website Has to Continue the Brand Experience

Here’s where things can fall apart.

Let’s say you create a Reel that reaches 50,000 people.

Five hundred people visit your profile.

Fifty people click through to your website.

That’s great.

But then your website is slow.

Maybe it’s confusing or it doesn’t look anything like your Instagram.

Perhaps there’s no obvious booking button.

The availability might be difficult to find.

Or the experience feels completely different from the one you just created on social media.

Social media did its job.

The website didn’t.

That’s why I don’t think you can evaluate your marketing channels completely on their own.

It could be that your social media is driving traffic, but your website simply isn’t converting that traffic.

Your website needs to continue the same brand experience someone encountered on social media.

The goal is to have photography, copywriting, branding, design, messaging, amenities, and booking experience all feel like they’re telling the same story.

Because they are.

---

Your Direct Booking Site Is Part of the Strategy

This is also why I keep coming back to having your own direct booking website.

If you’re relying entirely on Airbnb, you’re ultimately relying on someone else’s platform to bring you customers.

When demand slows down, that can feel scary.

The hosts who feel the most steady aren’t necessarily the ones with the most bookings.

Often, they’re the ones who have built marketing systems and booking channels they actually control.

A direct booking website gives you another way to convert the audience you’ve worked so hard to build.

It’s not just about avoiding commission.

More importantly, it’s about building a business that isn’t completely dependent on someone else’s algorithm, marketplace, or customer relationship.

A slower season can actually be the perfect time to build that infrastructure.

Note: In the podcast episode, I mention Lodgify as the property management system I use for this. You can use code BMPOD20 for 20% off yearly and bi-yearly Lodgify plans through December 31, 2026.

---

Two Types of Easy Next Yeses

When you’re creating your social media content, I want you to start thinking about two different types of calls to action.

1. The Easy Next Yes That Happens on the Platform

This could be as simple as asking someone to comment a keyword.

For example:

“Comment GUIDE and I’ll send you our local guide.”

Or:

“Comment GIVEAWAY to enter for a chance to win a free stay.”

The person doesn’t have to leave Instagram right away.

Instead, they simply take a tiny action.

That’s the point.

From there, a tool like ManyChat can help move that conversation into their DMs and eventually direct them toward your website or email list.

The initial action is easy.

2. The Easy Next Yes That Gets Them Off the Platform

The next step might be:

“Click the link in our bio to book direct.”

Or:

“Join our email list for early access to our holiday dates.”

Maybe it’s:

“Download our free Bourbon Trail itinerary.”

The goal is to move someone from a platform you don’t own to a platform you do.

Now you have another opportunity to build the relationship.

---

Every Piece of Your Short-Term Rental Marketing Strategy Has a Job

One of my favorite things about thinking about marketing this way is that it takes some of the pressure off social media.

Instagram, your email and your website do not have to do everything.

Instead, each piece has a job.

Social media: Create awareness and introduce people to your brand.

Your profile: Help people understand who you are and what you offer.

Your website: Build trust, communicate the experience, and provide the next step.

Email marketing: Continue the relationship and nurture potential guests.

Your direct booking site: Make the transaction easy.

Your branding and guest experience: Give people a reason to choose you.

Most importantly, all of those pieces should work together.

---

Stop Asking, “Why Isn’t Instagram Converting?”

Instead, ask a better question:

Where is the guest getting stuck?

Maybe people aren’t discovering you.

That’s a social media problem.

Maybe they’re discovering you but don’t understand what your property is.

That’s a messaging or profile problem.

Maybe they’re visiting your website but leaving right away.

That’s a website or conversion problem.

Perhaps they’re visiting your website but never booking because there’s no reason to take the next step.

That’s where your email marketing or offer might come in.

The goal isn’t to blame or abandon one marketing channel.

Instead, look at the entire journey.

Sometimes social media is working perfectly.

It’s just handing the next part of the job to a website that isn’t ready for it.

---

You Don’t Need to Build Your Short-Term Rental Marketing Strategy All at Once

If you’re reading this and thinking, Okay, now I need a social media strategy, a new website, an email list, a welcome sequence, a direct booking site, a lead magnet, and a whole marketing funnel…

Take a breath.

No.

The answer is not to do everything all at once.

That’s a surefire way to burn yourself out.

Instead, ask yourself:

What’s the next marketing channel that will create the greatest leverage for where my business is right now?

Maybe it’s finally creating your direct booking website.

Maybe it’s fixing the website you already have.

Perhaps you need to start building your email list.

Maybe your social media needs some attention because nobody is discovering you in the first place.

Or maybe your content is great, but your calls to action are missing.

Start there.

Build the next piece.

Then connect it to the piece you already have.

After that, keep going.

---

Build the Web, One Connection at a Time

Your marketing strategy doesn’t need to be a collection of random tactics you’re trying to keep up with.

Instead, it should be a connected system.

Someone discovers you on social media.

They learn more about you, visit your website, join your email list, receive your welcome sequence, they hear from you again, and they remember your property.

Eventually, they have a reason to travel.

And when they’re ready?

You’re the property they remember.

That’s the goal.

Social media can create the introduction.

Email can continue the conversation.

Your website can build the bridge.

And your direct booking site can make it easy to say yes.

You don’t need every piece to work independently.

You need them to work together.

That is the difference between simply posting on social media and actually having a marketing strategy.

---

Ready to Figure Out Where to Start?

If you’re not sure which part of your short-term rental marketing strategy needs your attention first, I’ve created a Short-Term Rental Marketing Quiz to help you figure it out.

It will point you toward the area of marketing that makes the most sense for where your business is right now. It will also recommend additional Brand & Market Podcast episodes to help you take the next step.

And remember: you don’t have to build the entire spiderweb today.

Just figure out your next connection.